Here is a look at the options for two start pitchers in week five of the major league baseball season, covering May 2 – May 8. Lots of top players in the American League next week with Jon Lester, CC Sabathia, and Justin Verlander all throwing.
2 start pitchers week 6: the list below is focused on mixed leagues since in AL or NL only leagues in most cases you do not have the option to rotate starting pitchers with the smaller player pool. The pitchers below are listed in alphabetical order by team name per category.
American League:
Start them:
Jon Lester (BOS) ~ LAA (Haren), MIN (Pavano)
Clay Buchholz (BOS) ~ LAA (Weaver), MIN (Duensing)
Justin Verlander (DET) ~ NYY (Colon), @TOR (Litsch)
Dan Haren (LAA) ~ @BOS (Lester), CLE (Tomlin)
Jered Weaver (LAA) ~ @BOS (Buchholz), CLE (Masterson)
CC Sabathia (NYY) ~ @DET (Penny), @TEX (Ogando)
Alexi Ogando (TEX) ~ @SEA (Bedard), NYY (Sabathia)
Roll the Dice:
Jeremy Guthrie (BAL) ~ @CWS (Buehrle), TB (Shields)
Clay Buchholz (BOS) ~ LAA (Weaver), MIN (Duensing)
Mark Buehrle (CHW) ~ BAL (Guthrie), @SEA (Bedard)
Josh Tomlin (CLE) ~ @OAK (Ross), @LAA (Haren)
Bartolo Colon (NYY) ~ @DET (Verlander), @TEX (Holland)
Tyson Ross (OAK) ~ CLE (Tomlin), @KC (Francis)
Brandon McCarthy (OAK) ~ TEX (Holland), @KC (Hochevar)
Wade Davis (TB) ~ TOR (Reyes), @BAL (bergesen)
Buehrle has lost three in a row though he pitched better in his last outing allowing three runs in seven innings. It is feast or famine with Ross depending if his control his own. It was in his last start when he walked only one in seven innings against the Angels. For the season, he has nine walks and nine strikeouts in 16 1/3 innings. McCarthy faces his old team, the Texas Rangers in his first start. Control has been impeccable so far with only four walks allowed in 35 1/3 innings which offsets his .297 batting average against. Guthrie is another guy that has improved his walk rate in 2011 with only four allowed in 32 innings of work so far. Overall Davis’ numbers look okay, but it is of some concern that strikeouts are down and home run rate has been supressed so far with only one allowed in 33 innings, so expect the ERA to start to rise.
Sit Them:
Brad Bergesen (BAL) ~ @KC (Francis), TB (Davis)
Brad Penny (DET) ~ NYY (Sabathia), @TOR (Reyes)
Jeff Francis (KC) ~ BAL (Bergesen), OAK (Ross)
Tyler Chatwood (LAA) ~ @BOS (Beckett), CLE (Masterson)
Erik Bedard (SEA) ~ TEX (Ogando), CWS (Buehrle)
Derek Holland (TEX) ~ @OAK (McCarthy), NYY (Colon)
Jo-Jo Reyes (TOR) ~ @TB (Davis), DET (Penny)
Francis has been teed off on in his last two starts with 1o runs allowed in seven innings. For the season, batters are hitting .324 against him. Holland has a lot of promise but has not been able to translate his minor league success to the major leagues yet. Bedard has been too homer prone in the early going with seven long balls allowed in 25 2/3 innings.
Penny’s last two starts have been okay, but he has two tough matchups next week.
National League:
Start them:
Tommy Hanson (ATL) ~ MIL (Gallardo), @PHI (Oswalt)
Jair Jurrjens (ATL) ~ MIL (Estrada), @PHI (Lee)
Clayton Kershaw (LAD) ~ CHC (Russell), @NYM (Dickey)
Cole Hamels (PHI) ~ WAS (Hernandez), ATL (Hanson)
Roll the Dice:
Mike Leake (CIN) ~ HOU (Happ), @CHC (Coleman)
Anibal Sanchez (FLA) ~ @STL (McClellan), WAS (Hernandez)
Marco Estrada (MIL) ~ @ATL (Jurrjens), @STL (McClellan)
Yovani Gallardo (MIL) ~ @ATL (Hanson), @STL (McClellan)
Aaron Harang (SD) ~ PIT (McDonald), ARI (Saunders)
Ryan Vogelsong (SF) ~ @NYM (Dickey), COL (Rogers)
Kyle McClellan (STL) ~ FLA (Sanchez), MIL (Gallardo)
Kyle Lohse (STL) ~ FLA (Volstad), MIL (Narveson)
Tom Gorzelanny (WAS) ~ SF (Bumgarner), @FLA (Volstad)
Livan Hernandez (WAS) ~ @PHI (Oswalt), @FLA (Sanchez)
Harang has actually been worse at home than on the road, with a 5.00 ERA at PETCO Park vs. 2.25 on the road. Gorzelanny is winless on the season but has had three straight solid outings allowing five runs in 17 1/3 innings.
Back in the major leagues for the first time since 2006, Vogelsong has looked good in limited action filling in for Barry Zito in the Giants rotation. Who needs Zack Greinke when you have Marco Estrada? Estrada has a 3.00 ERA through 21 innings and a 1.00 WHIP. Gallardo is a borderline bench with his numbers so far this season. On the plus side, he has faced Atlanta already once this season and tossed nine shutout innings against them.
Sit Them:
Joe Saunders (ARI) ~ (Rogers), @SD (Harang)
Esmil Rogers (COL) ~ @ARI (Saunders), @SF (Vogelsong)
Chris Volstad (FLA) ~ @STL (Lohse), WAS (Gorzelanny)
J.A. Happ (HOU) ~ @CIN (Leake), @PIT (McDonald)
R.A. Dickey (NYM) ~ SF (Vogelsong), LAD (Kershaw)
James McDonald (PIT) ~ @SD (Harang), HOU (Happ)
Madison Bumgarner (SF) ~ @WAS (Gorzelanny), COL (Jimenez)
Bumgarner is 0-4 on the season, thanks to bad pitching and a lack of offensive support as the Giants have scored only 8 runs for him in five starts. Dickey’s WHIP is a killer over a two start week at 1.55 due to a combination of walks and a .286 batting average against


