Here is the second article in the series for 2011 fantasy baseball rankings looking at the position of first base. This is a loaded position at the top of the draft with not many players with upside later on. If you are looking for players late in the draft, you are going to looking at players like rookie Freddie Freeman of Atlanta or hoping for progress from guys like Justin Smoak in Seattle or Matt LaPorta in Cleveland.
1. Albert Pujols – only quibble is his batting average has dropped for two straight years, but is still easily sits in the .300 range. Stolen bases remained in double digits which is a good sign. Still the landslide number one pick in fantasy baseball drafts.
2. Joey Votto – it was a breakout year for Votto with 37 home runs, 113 RBI and 16 stolen bases. Improving plate discipline coupled with his ability to swipe double digit steals will make him the second first basemen drafted after Pujols in 2011.
3. Miguel Cabrera – scored 100+ runs for the first time since 2006. Something to be said for his durability and consistency, driving in 100+ runs for the 7th straight season. Now has a career batting average of .313.
4. Adrian Gonzalez – the trade to Boston, plus the move away from Petco Park should mean a banner year for Gonzalez in 2011. Only small negative compared to the top tier first basemen is his batting average which has only once been over .300.
5. Mark Teixeira – has had significant fluctuations in batting average the last two years since coming back to the American League due to a struggle against right-handed pitching. Has hit 30+ home runs every season since 2003. Hit much better at home last season at .288 vs. only .227 on the road.
6. Ryan Howard – ended his streak of 40+ home run seasons at four. Power dropped off against right-handed pitching for some reason. The batting average was okay, but losing 14 home runs for a guy that was a first round pick in most drafts was tough to swallow.
7. Prince Fielder – ended the season with okay numbers but not what you needed from a guy that was a first round pick. Looming free agency seems to be impacting his performance at the plate. Drops across the board in power, RBI and batting average. Biggest problem was his struggles against left-handed pitching, hitting only .226 with a measly 19 RBI in 199 at bats.
8. Justin Morneau – was headed for his fourth 30+ home run season in his last five years before injuries hit. His .345 batting average was 24 points higher than his previous best. He has alternated batting over and under .300 his last five seasons so if he continues that trend in 2011, expect something in the .280 range. Struggled to hit home runs in his new ballpark, hitting only four of his 18 home runs at Target Field.
9. Kevin Youkilis – injuries ended his 2010 season early, otherwise he was in line for a season comparable to previous years. With the signings of Carl Crawford and the trade for Adrian Gonzalez, he might be hitting a spot or two lower in the lineup after hitting cleanup in 2010. Scores a ton of runs thanks to an on base percentage close to .400. Has played in less games every year since 2006 so there are some durability issues with owning him.
10. Kendry Morales – season ended early after suffering an injury in a home run celebration. Before that, he was on his way to duplicating his 2009 season. Draft ranking should be much the same as it was last season.
11. Adam Dunn - move to the Chicago White Sox in the American League should help him the next few years with the ability to DH and play in a better lineup. Has hit 38 or more home runs every season since 2004.
12. Paul Konerko – his 39 home runs were the most since 2005 and his .312 average was the best since 2006, so in other words don’t expect a repeat in 2011. Was on fire at home, hitting .342 with 26 home runs and 64 RBI in 260 at bats.
13. Billy Butler – the breakout season that many were expecting never came. Still hit a ton of doubles (45), but lost six home runs and drove in less baserunners. Will be only 25 the first month of the season so there is still some room for growth in the power department.
14. Aubrey Huff – enjoyed his first season with the San Francisco Giants and was rewarded with a two-year contract. Power dropped off in the second half of the season, hitting 17 home runs before the All-Star break and only nine after it.
15. Gaby Sanchez – became the starter at first base at age 26. Tailed off the second half of the season, hitting only .237 after batting .302 before the All-Star break. Also hit much better at home, batting .304 vs. .234 on the road.
16. Ike Davis – not a bad rookie campaign for Davis who was just a first round pick of the New York Mets back in 2008. Good to see him fare well as a young player against southpaws, hitting .295 against them in 122 at bats.Power and batting average were pretty similar in both the first and second half of the season.
17. Derrek Lee – had a predictable drop-off from his bust out 2009 season. Was better the second half of the season hitting .298 vs. .233 in the first part of the year. Still looking for a new team in 2011 as a free agent.
18. James Loney – hard to own him with little power and a lack of runs scored. His stolen bases plus his batting average has held up his value so far but is close to being replaced either through a trade or through a prospect if he cannot hit for more power. Only bright side was his 41 doubles, if a few of those can turn into home runs in 2011, he should have a bit more value. Hit just .211 after the All-Star break with 25 RBI in 251 at bats.
19. Carlos Pena - batting average has dropped for three straight years and if he is hitting less than 30 home runs, then he becomes just another guy. Moves to the National League for the first time so no guarantee that his average is going to rebound despite moving away from the American League East.
20. Adam LaRoche – looking for a new home as a free agent which means it will be his fifth team in the last three seasons. Despite his movement, he is pretty consistent with mid 20 home runs and 80 to 90 RBI every season.


