Here is the first article in the series for 2011 fantasy baseball rankings looking at the position of catcher. It will be interesting to see how fantasy baseball drafts unfold in March with Buster Posey, Carlos Santana and Matt Wieters likely having the biggest variances in average draft position of the top catchers, simply because they are young and don’t have a long track record.
As you will note from the rankings below, I have Jesus Montero listed as catcher. If he starts in the major leagues, he will not qualify at catcher for one to three weeks depending on your leagues requirement for games played by position. With Jorge Posada headed for the designated hitter role, Montero has a shot if the Yankees don’t sign anyone.
1. Joe Mauer – his numbers in 2010 were much in line with his 2008 season. Many people expected him to close to 20 home runs and he did not even make it half way there. His new home ballpark Target Field seemed to definitely have an impact as he hit only one home run there compared to seven at home in 2008. Value is still high due to his batting average and runs scored.
2. Victor Martinez – now with the Detroit Tigers, will serve as designated hitter and part-time catcher. Led all catchers in RBI last season with 79, despite missing 20+ games due to injury. Has not fared well at Comerica Park in his career, hitting .225 in 169 at bats with four home runs and 19 RBI.
3. Brian McCann – led the National League in RBI for catchers last year and has been as consistent as they come with more than 20 home runs in four of his last five seasons. Walk rate took a big step forward in 2010 with 74 free passes in 479 at bats.
4. Buster Posey – it was a banner year for Posey, claiming the NL Rookie of the Year award and managing a pitching staff that led the major leagues in ERA. Will likely be the fourth fantasy baseball catcher selected in drafts in 2011. Hit much better on road in 2010, with a .351 average, 12 home runs and 38 RBI.
5. Carlos Santana – the injury that ended his season early in 2010 does nothing to diminish his value. Will likely go in the top 10 rounds of your fantasy baseball draft and some will value him like they did Wieters last year. Has great plate discipline and should have a solid year in 2011.
6. Kurt Suzuki – His stats would have been close to his 2009 numbers outside of batting average if he had not missed 20+ games. Really struggled hitting third, batting just .222 with two home runs compared to hitting clean up where he hit .272 with 9 home runs and 35 RBI in 191 at bats. Struggled the second half of the season, hitting .233 with only three home runs in 249 at bats.
7. Geovany Soto – caught barely 100 hundred games for the second year in a row as arthroscopic surgery on his shoulder ended his season early. When he did play, he looked more like the 2008 version and not the guy in 2009 that hit only .218.
8. Mike Napoli – looked to be headed for a season low on playing time before the injury to Kendry Morales occurred. Hit 26 home runs despite hitting none in April while getting only 42 at bats. Will lose some at bats to Jeff Mathis at catcher if he remains with the Angels.
9. Miguel Montero – suffered a torn meniscus in early April and ended up playing in only 85 games. When he returned, he was hacking at the plate, striking out almost as many times as he did in 2009 in 128 less at bats. I would still value him close to his 2009 season with a little lower batting average.
10. Matt Wieters – I wrote last year he was likely a year away from making the jump to a McCann level and his numbers were worse than most expected. Hard to fathom him scoring only 37 runs in 446 at bats. Showed some slight improvement the second half of the year as his plate discipline improved. Will have to watch his ADP in spring to see where he is going. Could be a good value play or he may be over hyped again. Need to have a little patience as he had just 578 at bats in the minor leagues before he was promoted.
11. Miguel Olivo – it looked like he was going to be in a time share in Colorado with Chris Ianetta but took the job away with a first half that saw him hit .325 with 11 home runs. Fell back to the earth after the All-Star break with a .193 average in 166 at bats. Just signed with the Seattle Mariners and should be good for 15 home runs again in 2011.
12. Jorge Posada – turns 40 in August next season as age is starting to take a toll on him. Has not had more than 400 at bats since 2007. If you draft him in mixed leagues, you will need to grab a catcher for your reserve squad in order to replace Posada when he is out.
13. Jesus Montero – I have him slotted for 400 at bats in order to get this ranking. With Posada headed to designated hitter, Montero could get his shot unless the Yankees sign a free agent. Regardless if they do, they are going to need to find room for his bat in the lineup at some point in 2011.
14. John Jaso – not a bad year for Jaso who was nowhere on the fantasy radar heading into the 2010 season. Had better numbers hitting leadoff where he had a .272 average with three home runs and 16 RBI in 169 at bats. Has extra value in leagues with an on base percentage or OPS category.
15. A.J. Pierzynski – just resigned for two years with the White Sox so prospect Tyler Flowers will remain in Triple-A for at least another season. Has had more than 460 at bats every season since 2003. Boosted his batting average by the end of the year, hitting .299 after the All-Star break.
16. Yadier Molina – Has some value as a second catcher in fantasy baseball leagues but lacks one solid category to start in one catcher leagues unless it is extremely deep. Kept his steals and broke 60 RBI, but has show little power and scores very few runs.
17. Carlos Ruiz – came on strong after the All-Star break, hitting .316 with six home runs and 40 RBI as he saw more consistent playing time. Batting average has gone up 83 points over the last two years. Has added value in leagues where on base percentage is a category.
18. Chris Snyder – no doubt about the power, the question is can you afford to have his batting average on your roster? Luckily the impact is not as big as another position since he will likely be around 350 at bats or so.
19. John Buck - turned his 2010 career year into a three year contract with the Florida Marlins. One of numerous Blue Jay players to see a jump in home runs last year. Has a career batting average of .243 so don’t think he all of a sudden has become a good average hitter.
20. Russell Martin – Martin was headed toward another year similar to 2009 before injuring his hip in August which ended his season after he had played 97 games. Now a free agent, he is looking for a new home after the Dodgers signed Rod Barajas. Seems to be following a similar path to Jason Kendall at the same age range with a drop in his stolen bases.


