Here is a look at the options for two start pitchers in week four of the major league baseball season, covering April 18 – April 24th. Because of the rain out in Philadelphia, Joe Blanton becomes a two start pitcher next week getting the start on Monday.
2 start pitchers week 4: the list below is focused on mixed leagues since in AL or NL only leagues in most cases you do not have the option to rotate starting pitchers with the smaller player pool. The pitchers below are listed in alphabetical order by team name per category.
American League:
Start them:
John Danks (CHW) ~ @TB (Shields), @DET (Scherzer)
Edwin Jackson (CHW) ~ @TB (Price), @DET (Penny)
Brett Anderson (OAK) ~ BOS (Lackey), @SEA (Fister)
David Price (TB) ~ CWS (Jackson), @TOR (Litsch)
C.J. Wilson (TEX) ~ LAA (Santana), KC (Chen)
Ricky Romero (TOR) ~ @BOS (Matsuzaka), TB (Shields)
Roll the Dice:
Carlos Carrasco (CLE) ~ @KC (Davies), @MIN (Pavano)
Mitch Talbot (CLE) ~ @KC (Chen), @MIN (Pavano)
Max Scherzer (DET) ~ @SEA (Vargas), CWS (Danks)
Bruce Chen (KC) ~ CLE (Talbot), @TEX (Wilson)
Ervin Santana (LAA) ~ @TEX (Wilson), BOS (Matsuzaka)
Carl Pavano (MIN) ~ @BAL (Arrieta), CLE (Talbot)
Francisco Liriano (MIN) ~ @BAL (Tillman), CLE (Carrasco)
Jason Vargas (SEA) ~ DET (Scherzer), OAK (Cahill)
Doug Fister (SEA) ~ DET (Coke), OAK (Anderson)
James Shields (TB) ~ CWS (Danks), @TOR (Romero)
Liriano is a tough call with three straight losses to star the season and his control has not been as good with nine walks in 14 1/3 innings so far this season. I think it is still too early to bench your top tier pitcher pitchers that you took in the top half of your fantasy baseball draft unless there has been new of an injury. Chen has been sharp so far with a 2.37 ERA and a 1.11 WHIP through three starts, though he won’t pile up a ton of strikeouts. Fister’s numbers aren’t great, but he has always been a much better pitcher at home and he gets two starts at Safeco Field next week.
Sit Them:
Chris Tillman (BAL) ~ MIN (Liriano), NYY (Nova)
Jake Arrieta (BAL) ~ MIN (Pavano), NYY (Garcia)
John Lackey (BOS) ~ @OAK (Anderson), @LAA (Palmer)
Daisuke Matsuzaka (BOS) ~ TOR (Romero, @LAA (Santana)
Kyle Davies (KC) ~ CLE (Carrasco), @TEX (Ogando)
Matt Palmer (LAA) ~ @TEX (Lewis), BOS (Lackey)
Lackey had his last start skipped due to a rain day but was pounded in his first two starts against the Texas Rangers and New York Yankees. While they are two of the better offenses in the American League, his fastball has also been down a couple of miles per hour from 2010 as well.
National League:
Start them:
Tim Hudson (ATL) ~ @LAD (Lilly), @SF (Bumgarner)
Travis Wood (CIN) ~ ARI (Galarraga), @STL (Westbrook)
Josh Johnson (FLA) ~ PIT (Maholm), COL (Rogers)
Shaun Marcum (MIL) ~ @PHI (Blanton), HOU (Rodriguez)
Roy Halladay (PHI) ~ MIL (Wolf), @SD (Moseley)
Tim Lincecum (SF) ~ @COL (Rogers), ATL (Beachy)
Halladay will go on Tuesday instead of Monday but will still get two starts because the Phillies has seven games in week 4.
Roll the Dice:
Brandon Beachy (ATL) ~ @LAD (Kuroda), @SF (Lincecum)
Sam LeCure (CIN) ~ PIT (Correia), @STL (Carpenter)
Wandy Rodriguez (HOU) ~ NYM (Niese), @MIL (Marcum)
Hiroki Kuroda (LAD) ~ ATL (Beachy), @CHC (Russell)
Ted Lilly (LAD) ~ ATL (Hudson), @CHC (Dempster)
Jon Niese (NYM) ~ @HOU (Rodriguez), ARI (Galarraga)
Joe Blanton (PHI) ~ MIL (Marcum), @SD (Stauffer)
Kevin Correia (PIT) ~ @CIN (LeCure), WAS (Hernandez)
Tim Stauffer (SD) ~ @CHC (Russell), PHI (Blanton)
John Lannan (WAS) ~ @STL (Westbrook), @PIT (Maholm)
LeCure has been one of the surprises of the National League, with more than a strikeout per inning and holding hitters to a .105 average through 12 innings. Stauffer was brilliant last season but has not made it to the fifth inning in his past two starts. I would be okay with keeping him benched next week if you have other options. Correia has seen a huge drop in his strikeout rate but his other numbers have been better as he has a 2.70 ERA and a 1.10 WHIP through 20 innings.
Sit Them:
Armando Galarraga (AZ) ~ @CIN (Wood), @NYM (TBD)
James Russell (CHC) ~ SD (Stauffer), LAD (Kuroda)
Esmil Rogers (COL) ~ SF (Lincecum), @FLA (Johnson)
Paul Maholm (PIT) ~ @FLA (Johnson), WAS (Lannan)
Dustin Moseley (SD) ~ @CHC (Zambrano), PHI (Halladay)
Jake Westbrook (STL) ~ WAS (Lannan), CIN (Wood)
Yes, Moseley has pitched well this season, but has had zero runs scored for him in all three starts, has more walks than strikeouts on the season and has a tough matchup with Roy Halladay in his second start. Westbrook has had goo control in the past, but with 11 walks in 15 1/3 innings, he needs to be reserved until he can get that turned around.