The 2010 NL Tout Wars auction was held this past weekend in New York City. Tout Wars is fantasy baseball’s battle of the experts and winning one of the Tout Wars leagues is one of the more prestigious titles in fantasy baseball.
Here is a look at the 2010 NL Tout Wars results, the participants and their teams with my comments added.
Tristan Cockcroft – ESPN
Pick I liked: Kyle Blanks at $15. I think Blanks breaks out this season with 25-30 home runs and a few stolen bases thrown in.
Pick I disliked: Cameron Maybin at $18. Still has not proven he is ready for the major leagues and there were better options at this price.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Yadier Molina | 11 |
| C | Carlos Ruiz | 8 |
| 1B | Fernando Tatis | 2 |
| 3B | David Wright | 34 |
| CI | Juan Francisco | 1 |
| 2B | Placido Polanco | 16 |
| SS | Alcides Escobar | 16 |
| MI | Brendan Ryan | 9 |
| OF | Nate McLouth | 23 |
| OF | Carlos Gonzalez | 23 |
| OF | Kyle Blanks | 15 |
| OF | Seth Smith | 7 |
| OF | Cameron Maybin | 18 |
| UT | Ryan Spilborghs | 2 |
| P | Heath Bell | 18 |
| P | Ricky Nolasco | 19 |
| P | Ubaldo Jimenez | 17 |
| P | Huston Street | 9 |
| P | Mike Adams | 4 |
| P | Franklin Morales | 4 |
| P | Rafael Betancourt | 2 |
| P | Jeff Francis | 1 |
| P | Daniel McCutchen | 1 |
| R | Wade LeBlanc | |
| R | Mike Leake | |
| R | Jeremy Affeldt | |
| R | Jamie Moyer |
Mike Gianella – Roto Think Tank
Pick I liked: Jose Reyes at $23. A risky pick yes, but the upside for that price is worth it.
Pick I disliked: Kenshin Kawakami at $8. It looks like they were better pitchers to buy for that price.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Ronny Paulino | 3 |
| C | Yorvit Torrealba | 1 |
| 1B | Albert Pujols | 40 |
| 3B | Mat Gamel | 2 |
| CI | Joey Votto | 28 |
| 2B | Ronnie Belliard | 3 |
| SS | Jose Reyes | 23 |
| MI | Hanley Ramirez | 40 |
| OF | Carlos Lee | 24 |
| OF | Alfonso Soriano | 18 |
| OF | Eric Young | 3 |
| OF | Josh Anderson | 1 |
| OF | Mike Stanton | 1 |
| UT | Cristian Guzman | 3 |
| P | Matt Cain | 19 |
| P | Carlos Marmol | 15 |
| P | Matt Capps | 12 |
| P | Madison Bumgarner | 2 |
| P | Chris Volstad | 3 |
| P | John Maine | 3 |
| P | Paul Maholm | 5 |
| P | John Lannan | 3 |
| P | Kenshin Kawakami | 8 |
| R | Sean Gallagher | |
| R | Travis Wood | |
| R | Aaron Cunningham | |
| R | Roger Bernhidina |
Phil Hertz – Baseball HQ
Pick I liked: Josh Willingham at $15. Hard to pick a player I liked as all of his players seemed to be bought right at their expected price.
Pick I disliked: Stephen Drew at $22.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Ivan Rodriguez | 4 |
| C | Jason Castro | 1 |
| 1B | Adam LaRoche | 20 |
| 3B | Ryan Zimmerman | 34 |
| CI | Gaby Sanchez | 9 |
| 2B | Akinori Iwamura | 10 |
| SS | Stephen Drew | 22 |
| MI | Kelly Johnson | 17 |
| OF | Shane Victorino | 24 |
| OF | Josh Willingham | 15 |
| OF | Chris Young | 15 |
| OF | Lastings Milledge | 18 |
| OF | Marlon Byrd | 15 |
| UT | Bobby Crosby | 1 |
| P | Chad Qualls | 19 |
| P | Chris Young (P) | 7 |
| P | Brett Myers | 8 |
| P | Aaron Harang | 7 |
| P | Derek Lowe | 8 |
| P | Jason Motte | 3 |
| P | Sean Marshall | 1 |
| P | Sammy Gervacio | 1 |
| P | Josh Lindbaum | 1 |
| R | Ike Davis | |
| R | Todd Coffey | |
| R | Tony Abreu | |
| R | Scott Elbert |
Peter Kreutzer – Askrotoman.com
Pick I liked: Jim Edmonds at $1. I think he ends the season with a lot more at bats than people are expecting.
Pick I disliked: Too many injury risks with Lance Berkman, Aramis Ramirez, Carlos Beltran, Elijah Dukes (cut), Brandon Webb, Edison Volquez.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Ryan Doumit | 11 |
| C | Buster Posey | 3 |
| 1B | Lance Berkman | 23 |
| 3B | Aramis Ramirez | 24 |
| CI | Andy LaRoche | 8 |
| 2B | Clint Barmes | 13 |
| SS | Yunel Escobar | 18 |
| MI | Felipe Lopez | 9 |
| OF | Ryan Braun | 38 |
| OF | Drew Stubbs | 14 |
| OF | Carlos Beltran | 18 |
| OF | Angel Pagan | 5 |
| OF | Elijah Dukes | 1 |
| UT | Jim Edmonds | 1 |
| P | Roy Halladay | 30 |
| P | Chris Carpenter | 21 |
| P | Brandon Webb | 9 |
| P | Edwin Jackson | 8 |
| P | Manny Parra | 1 |
| P | Rick VandenHurk | 2 |
| P | Edinson Volquez | 1 |
| P | Aaron Cook | 1 |
| P | Joel Hanrahan | 1 |
| R | Tyler Colvin | |
| R | Jordan Schafer | |
| R | Evan Meek | |
| R | Ken Mulvey |
Chris Liss – Rotowire
Pick I liked: Jason Heyward at $14. He was a better buy in the outfield that some players that went for several dollars more than him that I have ranked below him.
Pick I disliked: Jermaine Dye at $3. Hard to see him signing this late in spring, especially with a National League team.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Russell Martin | 14 |
| C | Miguel Montero | 15 |
| 1B | Todd Helton | 15 |
| 3B | Ian Stewart | 18 |
| CI | David Freese | 9 |
| 2B | Kaz Matsui | 11 |
| SS | Orlando Cabrera | 15 |
| MI | Edgar Renteria | 8 |
| OF | Justin Upton | 34 |
| OF | Jason Heyward | 14 |
| OF | Colby Rasmus | 18 |
| OF | Melky Cabrera | 8 |
| OF | Jermaine Dye | 3 |
| UT | Pedro Alvarez | 4 |
| P | Johan Santana | 25 |
| P | Aroldis Chapman | 5 |
| P | Brad Lidge | 11 |
| P | Randy Wells | 6 |
| P | Homer Bailey | 7 |
| P | Kris Medlen | 3 |
| P | Joe Blanton | 11 |
| P | John Garland | 4 |
| P | Felipe Paulino | 2 |
| R | Mike Jacobs | |
| R | Kyle Kendrick | |
| R | Jason Giambi | |
| R | Pedro Martinez |
Lenny Melnick & Paul Greco – Fantasy Pros 911
Pick I liked: Willy Taveras at $1. Nice late game pick for some cheap speed.
Pick I disliked: Rickie Weeks at $24. Much too high of a price to pay for someone that injury prone.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Ryan Hanigan | 1 |
| C | Omar Santos | 1 |
| 1B | Prince Fielder | 37 |
| 3B | Scott Rolen | 10 |
| CI | Geo Blum | 1 |
| 2B | Rickie Weeks | 24 |
| SS | Troy Tulowitzki | 31 |
| MI | Starlin Castro | 1 |
| OF | Matt Holliday | 34 |
| OF | Hunter Pence | 28 |
| OF | Nate Schierholtz | 10 |
| OF | Wil Venable | 15 |
| OF | Xavier Nady | 3 |
| UT | Wily Taveras | 1 |
| P | Josh Johnson | 20 |
| P | Clayton Kershaw | 21 |
| P | Carlos Zambrano | 12 |
| P | Ross Ohlendorf | 2 |
| P | Oliver Perez | 3 |
| P | Mike Pelfrey | 2 |
| P | LaTroy Hawkins | 1 |
| P | Juan Gutierrez | 1 |
| P | Kyle McClellan | 1 |
| R | Luis Durango | |
| R | Allen Craig | |
| R | Gary Matthews | |
| R | Craig Counsell |
Scott Pianowski – Yahoo
Pick I liked: Ian Desmond at $10. Now that he has won the job as starting shortstop, he has a good chance to hit double digit home runs with 20+ steals.
Pick I disliked: Barry Zito at $5.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Bengie Molina | 12 |
| C | Chris Iannetta | 11 |
| 1B | Ryan Howard | 34 |
| 3B | Mark DeRosa | 11 |
| CI | Aubrey Huff | 13 |
| 2B | Adam Kennedy | 9 |
| SS | Ian Desmond | 10 |
| MI | Skip Schumaker | 9 |
| OF | Manny Ramirez | 21 |
| OF | Ben Francisco | 4 |
| OF | Brad Hawpe | 18 |
| OF | Jeff Francoeur | 14 |
| OF | Willie Harris | 4 |
| UT | Troy Glaus | 16 |
| P | Adam Wainwright | 24 |
| P | Ryan Franklin | 13 |
| P | Matt Lindstrom | 9 |
| P | Johnny Cueto | 9 |
| P | Barry Zito | 5 |
| P | Bronson Arroyo | 8 |
| P | Zach Duke | 2 |
| P | Jason Marquis | 2 |
| P | Tom Gorzelanny | 2 |
| R | Omar Inante | |
| R | Todd Wellemeyer | |
| R | Reed Johnson | |
| R | Sinori Takahashi |
Nate Ravitz – ESPN
Pick I liked: Casey McGehee at $10. Decent batting average and some power for a decent price.
Pick I disliked: Dan Haren at $28. I love Dan Haren but there were comparable pitchers to be had for $4-$6 less.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Ramon Hernandez | 8 |
| C | Jesus Flores | 2 |
| 1B | Adrian Gonzalez | 28 |
| 3B | Casey McGehee | 10 |
| CI | Adam Dunn | 23 |
| 2B | Dan Uggla | 21 |
| SS | Ryan Theriot | 16 |
| MI | Freddy Sanchez | 10 |
| OF | Matt Kemp | 38 |
| OF | Eugenio Velez | 3 |
| OF | Tony Gwynn | 7 |
| OF | Delwyn Young | 3 |
| OF | Chris Dickerson | 7 |
| UT | John Bowker | 2 |
| P | Dan Haren | 28 |
| P | Billy Wagner | 17 |
| P | Trevor Hoffman | 15 |
| P | Takashi Saito | 3 |
| P | Mat Latos | 8 |
| P | Brad Penny | 4 |
| P | Dan Runzler | 1 |
| P | David Bush | 3 |
| P | Anibal Sanchez | 3 |
| R | Logan Morrison | |
| R | Oscar Salazar | |
| R | Esmailin Caridad | |
| R | Jarrod Washburn |
Larry Schechter – Sandlot Shrink
Pick I liked: Garrett Jones at $14. Has 20+ home run power, can steal a few bases and qualifies at first base and in the outfield.
Pick I disliked: Chase Headley at $17. A few dollars higher than what he should have gone for.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | John Baker | 8 |
| C | Miguel Olivo | 6 |
| 1B | Garrett Jones | 14 |
| 3B | Jorge Cantu | 18 |
| CI | Casey Blake | 14 |
| 2B | Luis Castillo | 9 |
| SS | Rafael Furcal | 15 |
| MI | David Eckstein | 3 |
| OF | Nyjer Morgan | 20 |
| OF | Ryan Ludwick | 18 |
| OF | Aaron Rowand | 9 |
| OF | Chase Headley | 17 |
| OF | Kosuke Fukudome | 9 |
| UT | Jonny Gomes | 7 |
| P | Tim Lincecum | 34 |
| P | Francisco Cordero | 16 |
| P | Jair Jurrjens | 16 |
| P | J.A. Happ | 8 |
| P | Vicente Padilla | 4 |
| P | Luke Gregersen | 4 |
| P | Charlie Morton | 3 |
| P | Bud Norris | 4 |
| P | Kyle Lohse | 4 |
| R | Nick Masset | |
| R | Alex Cora | |
| R | Dan Meyer | |
| R | Tim Stauffer |
Cory Schwartz – MLB.com
Pick I liked: Ian Kennedy at $6. Lots of upside, with decent ratios.
Pick I disliked: Andre Ethier at $29. A few dollars higher than what he should have cost.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Brian McCann | 24 |
| C | George Kottaras | 1 |
| 1B | Jeff Clement | 9 |
| 3B | Mark Reynolds | 28 |
| CI | Mike Fontenot | 6 |
| 2B | Drew Sutton | 1 |
| SS | Juan Uribe | 7 |
| MI | Ronny Cedeno | 3 |
| OF | Jayson Werth | 27 |
| OF | Andre Ethier | 29 |
| OF | Dexter Fowler | 18 |
| OF | Chris Coghlan | 17 |
| OF | Matt Diaz | 9 |
| UT | Jody Gerut | 2 |
| P | Jonathan Broxton | 25 |
| P | Stephen Strasburg | 11 |
| P | Cole Hamels | 23 |
| P | Ian Kennedy | 6 |
| P | Hiroki Kuroda | 9 |
| P | John Grabow | 1 |
| P | Drew Storen | 2 |
| P | Brian Bruney | 1 |
| P | Billy Buckner | 1 |
| R | Hong Chi Kuo | |
| R | Rich Hill | |
| R | Manny Corpas | |
| R | Kevin Pucetas |
Brian Walton – Mastersball
Pick I liked: Everth Cabrera at $13 looks like a great price for a lead off hitter with the potential to steal 40+
Pick I disliked: Liked his pitching staff, he got a lot of solid guys, but I think that Jason Hammel at $7 was too much. It was almost overkill at that point with everyone he had on his staff.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Chris Snyder | 3 |
| C | Gregg Zaun | 5 |
| 1B | James Loney | 21 |
| 3B | Chipper Jones | 16 |
| CI | Daniel Murphy | 8 |
| 2B | Martin Prado | 16 |
| SS | Everth Cabrera | 13 |
| MI | Tommy Manzella | 4 |
| OF | Jay Bruce | 21 |
| OF | Carlos Gomez | 12 |
| OF | Corey Hart | 17 |
| OF | Conor Jackson | 18 |
| OF | Fred Lewis | 1 |
| UT | Gerardo Parra | 2 |
| P | Francisco Rodriguez | 18 |
| P | Chad Billingsley | 17 |
| P | Roy Oswalt | 16 |
| P | Tim Hudson | 12 |
| P | Jonathan Sanchez | 10 |
| P | Ryan Madson | 5 |
| P | Jorge De La Rosa | 11 |
| P | Jason Hammel | 7 |
| P | Jaime Garcia | 4 |
| R | Ryan Roberts | |
| R | Chien Ming Wang | |
| R | Freddie Freeman | |
| R | Craig Stammen |
Scott Wilderman – The Owners Edge
Pick I liked: Blake DeWitt at $5.
Pick I disliked: Pablo Sandoval at $33. Yikes !!!.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Nick Hundley | 6 |
| C | J.R. Towles | 3 |
| 1B | Derrek Lee | 26 |
| 3B | Pablo Sandoval | 33 |
| CI | Blake DeWitt | 5 |
| 2B | Jeff Keppinger | 5 |
| SS | Emilio Boniacio | 3 |
| MI | Jeff Baker | 1 |
| OF | Andrew McCutchen | 24 |
| OF | Jason Bay | 26 |
| OF | Raul Ibanez | 21 |
| OF | Michael Bourn | 21 |
| OF | Fernando Martinez | 1 |
| UT | Mike Morse | 1 |
| P | Brian Wilson | 20 |
| P | Tommy Hanson | 22 |
| P | Octavio Dotel | 11 |
| P | Yovani Gallardo | 20 |
| P | Brandon Lyon | 6 |
| P | Garrett Mock | 1 |
| P | Carlos Villanueva | 1 |
| P | Jonathan Niese | 2 |
| P | Jordan Zimmermann | 1 |
| R | Doug Davis | |
| R | Garret Anderson | |
| R | Clay Zavada | |
| R | Ronald Bellisario |
Todd Zola – Mastersball
Pick I liked: Scott Hairston at $6 if he can get 400+ at bats.
Pick I disliked: Too many part-time hitters on his team and he left $6 at the draft table. Cody Ross at $18 seemed too much for just his power when there were power / speed guys that went for around the same or slightly lower price.
| POS | Name | $$ |
| C | Giovany Soto | 15 |
| C | Rod Barajas | 5 |
| 1B | Micah Hoffpauir | 1 |
| 3B | Julio Lugo | 5 |
| CI | Pedro Feliz | 8 |
| 2B | Chase Utley | 37 |
| SS | Jimmy Rollins | 33 |
| MI | Brandon Phillips | 29 |
| OF | Cody Ross | 18 |
| OF | Eric Hinske | 3 |
| OF | Ryan Church | 3 |
| OF | Jerry Hairston | 7 |
| OF | Scott Hairston | 6 |
| UT | Melvin Mora | 3 |
| P | Leo Nunez | 12 |
| P | Wandy Rodriguez | 18 |
| P | Randy Wolf | 11 |
| P | Ryan Dempster | 14 |
| P | Ted Lilly | 12 |
| P | Kevin Correia | 7 |
| P | Clayton Richard | 4 |
| P | Sergio Romo | 2 |
| P | George Sherrill | 1 |
| R | Tyler Clippard | |
| R | Edward Mujica | |
| R | Justin Maxwell | |
| R | James McDonald |



You’re dead on about Kawakami, Todd. I had the same reaction in real time…there were a number of pitchers who went before Kenshin that I should have pulled the trigger on and didn’t.