Here is a look at the options for two start pitchers in week 26 of the major league baseball season, covering September 19 – September 25.
2 start pitchers week 26: the list below is focused on mixed leagues since in AL or NL only leagues in most cases you do not have the option to rotate starting pitchers with the smaller player pool. The pitchers below are listed in alphabetical order by team name per category.
American League:
Start them:
Ricky Romero (TOR) ~ LAA (Pineiro), @TB (Davis)
Roll the Dice:
Jeremy Guthrie (BAL) ~ @BOS (TBD), @DET (Penny)
Gavin Floyd (CHW) ~ @CLE (Carmona), KC (Chen)
Phil Hughes (NYY) ~ MIN (Pavano), BOS (Wakefield)
Wade Davis (TB) ~ @NYY (Burnett), TOR (Romero)
Derek Holland (TEX) ~ @OAK (Harden), SEA (Furbush)
Holland is 3-0 in his last four starts and tossed seven shutout innings in his last start against the Red Sox. Davis has two tough matchups next week against the Yankees who he has yet to face this season and the Blue Jays who he has a 4.91 ERA and 1.56 WHIP against in four starts this season. Hughes was better in his last two starts allowing three runs in 12 innings on the heels of getting rokced his two previous outings. He faced Boston three starts ago and allowed six runs in 5 2/3 innings and one run in 7 2/3 innings the last time he faced the Twins. Floyd did not make it to the sixth inning in either of his last three starts and faced Cleveland three times in his 10 starts, allowing six runs in 19 innings. Guthrie has allowed three runs or less in five straight starts, though he was knocked around the last time he faced the Tigers, allowing six runs in 5 2/3 innings.
Sit Them:
Rick VandenHurk (BAL) ~ @BOS (Weiland), @DET (Verlander)
David Huff (CLE) ~ SEA (Furbush), MIN (Pavano)
Fausto Carmona (CLE) ~ CWS (Floyd), MIN (Hendriks)
Brad Penny (DET) ~ @KC (Hochevar), BAL (Guthrie)
Jerome Williams (LAA) ~ @TOR (Morrow), OAK (Moscoso)
Joel Pineiro (LAA) ~ @TOR (Romero), OAK (Harden)
Liam Hendriks (MIN) ~ SEA (Vargas), @CLE (Carmona)
Carl Pavano (MIN) ~ @NYY (Hughes), @CLE (Huff)
A.J. Burnett (NYY) ~ TB (Davis), BOS (Lackey)
Rich Harden (OAK) ~ TEX (Holland), @LAA (Pineiro)
Charlie Furbush (SEA) ~ @CLE (Huff), @TEX (Holland)
Brandon Morrow (TOR) ~ LAA (Williams), @TB (Moore)
Pineiro has had two decent starts, an average start and one bad start since moving back into the Angels rotation. I would only look to start him if you are desperate for wins. Every once in awhile vintage Harden pops up from days gone by, but unless you can make up a lot of ground in strikeouts, it is tough to risk your ratios to two starts from him. He allowed four runs in four innings the last time he faced the Rangers. Williams has struggled on the road in two starts with a 7.62 ERA and a 2.08 WHIP and has a tough match up against Toronto next week. Carmona has not won since August 17th and has a 8.68 ERA and 2.09 WHIP for four starts in September. Despite Huff’s numbers overall on the season, I am not comfortable recommending him next week as has gotten exposed in his last three starts, allowing 10 runs in 16 1/3 innings. Morrow has been trending the wrong direction, allowing five runs or more in four of his last five starts. Furbush has lost five straight starts and allowed six runs in four innings the last time he faced Texas.
National League:
Start them:
Ian Kennedy (ARI) ~ PIT (Karstens), SF (Lincecum)
Clayton Kershaw (LAD) ~ SF (Lincecum), @SD (Luebke)
Cliff Lee (PHI) ~ WAS (Peacock), @NYM (Pelfrey)
Roy Halladay (PHI) ~ STL (Lohse), @NYM (Gee)
Cory Luebke (SD) ~ @COL (Millwood), LAD (Kershaw)
Tim Lincecum (SF) ~ @LAD (Kershaw), @ARI (Kennedy)
Edwin Jackson (STL) ~ NYM (Pelfrey), CHC (Coleman)
Roll the Dice:
Mike Minor (ATL) ~ @FLA (Nolasco), @WAS (Peacock)
Jhoulys Chacin (COL) ~ SD (Latos), @HOU (Norris)
Kevin Millwood (COL) ~ SD (Luebke), @HOU (Happ)
Bud Norris (HOU) ~ @CIN (Bailey), COL (Chacin)
Chris Narveson (MIL) ~ @CHC (Coleman), FLA (Hand)
Kyle Lohse (STL) ~ @PHI (Halladay), CHC (Dempster)
Brad Peacock (WAS) ~ @PHI (Lee), ATL (Minor)
Narveson had his last start skipped because of an off day and has not made it to the sixth inning in his last four starts making him a somewhat risky play. Millwood tossed seven shutout innings in his last start against the Padres, though it will be a little tougher at Coors Field this time. Chacin has been slowing down the second half of the season as the innings have piled up with a 4.76 ERA and 1.60 WHIP. I would be tempted to bench him if you have another alternative. Minor is 5-0 in his last eight starts and allowed one run in 5 2/3 innings in his last start against the Marlins.
Sit Them:
Casey Coleman (CHC) ~ MIL (Narveson), @STL (Jackson)
J.A. Happ (HOU) ~ @CIN (Maloney), COL (Millwood)
Mike Pelfrey (NYM) ~ @STL (Jackson), PHI (Lee)
Pelfrey faces St. Louis for the first time this season, but has struggled in five starts against the Phillies with a 6.84 ERA and a 1.68 WHIP. Happ has been better in his last four starts allowing six runs in 24 innings, but two starts came against the Pirates and one against the Giants.


